Open Thread: Oracle Hotline
Aug. 29th, 2026 04:10 pmIn good news, I've been approached by my publisher about doing an addition to my book now that one of the subjects is back from career-threatening injury! And it's basically formal fanfic that follows canon very closely, so I think I can apply questions to that project.
What would I like to do better this time around? I'm struggling to make sure that my writing doesn't sound too much like AI writing, to be honest. In part because so much AI was trained on reams of freely-available fanfic, AI writing has a lot of the tics and habits that my writing tends to have. I don't think it's any good weeding them all out (I'd be left with the flattest prose) but the writing goes more slowly when I'm constantly second-guessing myself. I guess really the true answer to this question is more "I'm trying to relax and not get too hung up on worrying about it."
(I also am trying to make sure I stop using "very" so much! I cannot break myself of this bad habit, lol).
I hope things are going well with you and your writing!
Open Thread: Oracle Hotline
Aug. 21st, 2026 04:10 pmOh, the anguish of writing a scene that somehow isn't working and you're not sure how to fix it! I think for me the hint is that it starts to feel like I'm running into a wall. What's going to come after this scene? It's like the road disappears into fog. That's usually my best indication that things are going off the rails and I have to back up and find a new path (which sometimes can take me WAY back, which is very depressing).
I hope whatever you're working on is going smoothly this week! I've been on the road visiting family, which was lovely, but it's also nice to be home (and talking about fanfic with you!)
Open Thread: Oracle Hotline
Aug. 2nd, 2026 02:11 pmWell, so far all of them, alas! Right now simply finding the time to write at all is almost impossible. In the past my most challenging scenes have always involved either the Joker or Harley Quinn, because writing erratic and unpredictable characters is always hard for me. Honestly I think once of my hardest scenes ever was at the climax of a fic where Harley was threatening Batman by putting civilians in danger, because between the logistics of creating the deathtrap and also having Harley be unpredictable I was really stretched thin! It took forever to get through it and my beta really had to re-write large swatches of it.
What have you struggled to get through and how did you do it?
Open Thread: Oracle Hotline
Jul. 25th, 2026 10:11 amOpen Thread: Oracle Hotline
Jul. 17th, 2026 09:34 amOpen Thread: Oracle Hotline
Jul. 11th, 2026 04:31 pmOpen Thread: Oracle Hotline
Jul. 3rd, 2026 09:44 amOpen Thread: Oracle Hotline
Jun. 26th, 2026 08:35 pmOpen Thread: Oracle Hotline
Jun. 19th, 2026 01:50 pm--We're all writing about people who have careers that are important to them. What details about their job—the routine, the paperwork, the small moments between crises—do you think add texture to your stories?
Superheroes are not known for doing a great deal of paperwork (one way I envy them!) But I do love writing those moments on the Watchtower in between crises when everyone is hanging out--there's got to be a few of them, right? In the AU I'm poking at, Clark is a sheriff, and there's a lot of down time keeping guard over criminals in the jail, for example, that serve a lot of the same purpose.
I was in the US last week playing watchdog for 26 young students, but am back to think about fic this week! (Speaking of job details...)
Open Thread: Oracle Hotline
Jun. 5th, 2026 09:54 amOpen Thread: Oracle Hotline
May. 31st, 2026 03:27 pmAKA the Cigarette Smoke Question! Having grown up in the 70s I can testify it was basically a fog that hung around everything.
Wild West in the 1880s... lot of dust, smoke, and horses! Clark likes to whittle in this world and keep his hands busy, so the sensory feeling of carving wood definitely is a part of it. (I just realized writing this that whittling a bat to silently give to Bruce would be a very nice way of letting him know he's figured out his secret identity!)
Open Thread: Oracle Hotline
May. 22nd, 2026 12:40 pmWe're all working in pretty different time periods and settings! I can definitely see some of the new technology marvels of the late 19th century being really key to the Gaslight universe--that steampunk influence. And also the frontier feeling of the West that permeates the most recent canon. There's a sense of wonder and exploration that really suits Clark especially, and contrasts nicely with the more "punk" side that Batman represents, all shadows and grime.
I know both Brady and Svgurl are writing in times and milieus that were much more repressive for same-sex couples, which is an extra challenge!
Open Thread: Oracle Hotline
May. 15th, 2026 10:47 amOpen Thread: Oracle Hotline
May. 9th, 2026 09:10 amWhat research have you been doing, whether it's into illnesses, flowers, New York or Edwardian times?
Open Thread: Oracle Hotline
May. 1st, 2026 07:20 pmOpen Thread: Oracle Hotline
Apr. 24th, 2026 08:14 amOpen Thread: Oracle Hotline
Apr. 17th, 2026 03:48 pmI think with fanfic this is an especially interesting question! How do you keep characters that you've lifted from canon and are giving their own, separate character arcs "recognizably themselves"? And... do you even want to? I think for a lot of people there's a joy in developing the characters off in their own direction. I like hewing fairly close to the originals most of the time, but now and then I do like just... untethering them from canon and seeing where they wander to...
Open Thread: Oracle Hotline
Apr. 10th, 2026 10:03 amThat's kind of a funny question for people writing anything superhero-related, because of all the genres in the world, I think superheroes are one of the most "your background and history determine who you are." Thus the idea of an "origin story," the event that literally set the course of the character's life, you know? It's hard, for example, to think of a way that Bruce is influenced by his background that he doesn't realize--he's kind of exquisitely aware of his own issues about guns and crime and parents, and how they drive him to take in orphans, etc. And Clark always seems very conscious of how being an alien immigrant shapes his actions and his views of the world. How about the versions of characters you're writing right now, maybe they're less self-aware?